Blog

February 4, 2013 by Emily Cohen

Are you still recovering from your INSANE Super Bowl party? Yeah, me neither. But, as I ate some nachos with my husband and watched all the people cheer on Ray Lewis, I really wanted to share my experience “playing” fantasy football. I have never been athletic or particularly competitive; I don’t even like watching pretend violence, let alone engaging in the real thing for “sport.” I did grow up in a sports-loving household—my mother still hasn’t forgiven the Dodgers for leaving Brooklyn—and I usually knew who I was rooting for.

Initially, I decided to join a fantasy football league because I thought it would be a fun hobby I could share with my husband. I also thought it would make watching games with him more enjoyable—and, much like marrying him in the first place, this proved to be another great decision.

This year, I’m proud to say I won my fantasy football Super Bowl. I played against a bunch of strangers I will never meet or know by anything other than their fantasy team and individual names—all of whom are men. How do I know this? Because any and all posts exchanged on the message boards involved the word “dude.” On several occasions, I was forced to clarify my own status: “Actually, I’m a ‘chick’” (I don’t know about you, but I personally wouldn’t describe myself as a “lady”).  

Years ago, I met a woman named Kathy Redmond. Redmond is the founder of the National Coalition Against Violent Athletes (NCAVA) and meeting her taught me about the very real impact of a campus or town’s sports fanaticism on its other inhabitants. Many college athletes develop aggressive, entitled, and larger than life personalities when they realize that thousands of people will continue to adore them, regardless of their behavior, as long as they continue to score points. Knowing that most professional athletes start out as college players, it’s not a stretch to imagine this attitude expanding and worsening with early draft picks and fat contracts.

This is where my love of research comes into play, aiding me in my unique draft preparation: Yes, I want high-performance players, but that is not my main priority. Sure, that guy might be fast, but has he been convicted of domestic violence? Or animal cruelty? I believe people should be considered innocent until proven guilty. And that, in most cases, if they’ve served their time, they’ve paid their debt to society.

But that doesn’t mean I want them on my team. That’s the beautiful thing about fantasy football: my team is made up of whomever I choose—or don’t choose. I would not draft Ray Lewis, but I would draft Brendon Ayanbadejo. If I am going to root for someone, I want to be able to root for him wholeheartedly—and not just on the field, but in general. I can’t know every detail about every person’s past—nor should I. Everyone makes a bad decision at some point in his or her life and no one is perfect.

And I know not all athletes are violent and not all football fans are men—but in my fantasy world, no one is violent and everyone is a feminist. Go team!

3 Reader Comments

Liz Mulligan-Ferry says:
2/4/2013 12:15:24

What a fantastic post. It's so unfortunate that your fantasy--taking all aspects of an athlete's behavior into account--is just that: a fantasy. This extends far beyond sports, too, into politics, entertainment, business... Imagine the world in which we could live if holistic evaluation was second nature. Kudos for bringing this to readers' attention.

Cathy Soto says:
2/4/2013 01:08:31

Congrats on winning! Its nice to know that someone else is also against the violence. I enjoy watching a variety of sports, football - NFL and LFL, basketball - NBA, and sometimes other sports as well. This was my first year doing fantasy football as well and I must say it was a blast being able to research who you want as a player.

Have a wonderful day!
Thanks, Cat

Laurie Petersen says:
2/8/2013 11:58:02

What I enjoyed most about this post is how you took account of all the behaviors in choosing a winning fantasy football team. As a one-time stats keeper -- breaking gender barriers at my high school -- I also appreciated how well you demonstrated women have a role to play in this game beyond cheerleading. Congratulations!

Leave A Comment